If you’ve been arrested in Florida, one of the first decisions you’ll face is this:
Should I hire a private criminal defense attorney—or rely on the public defender? If you’ve been arrested in Florida, one of the first questions you’ll face is whether to use a public defender or hire a private attorney. This guide explains the real difference in outcomes, strategy, and control—and why it matters in Florida criminal cases.
It’s a fair question. Public defenders are real lawyers. Some are excellent. But there are big differences between public and private representation—and the stakes couldn’t be higher.
Here’s what you need to know before you make a decision that could impact the rest of your life.
🔹 What Is a Public Defender?
A public defender is a court-appointed criminal defense lawyer provided at no cost if you can’t afford to hire one.
In Florida, public defenders handle all types of cases, from misdemeanors to serious felonies. However, they’re often juggling dozens—sometimes hundreds—of cases at once.
🧠 Key Differences: Public Defender vs. Private Criminal Attorney
Many clients ask us about the pros and cons of public defender vs private attorney Florida cases. Here’s a summary:
| Feature | Public Defender | Private Attorney |
|---|---|---|
| 🔄 Caseload | Very high | Selective |
| ⏱️ Time per client | Often limited | More individualized |
| 🧩 Strategy meetings | Infrequent | Custom and consistent |
| 📁 Case control | Court assigned | You choose who you hire |
| 📞 Availability | Often through staff | Direct communication |
📌 Related:Criminal Attorney vs. Criminal Defense Lawyer in Florida
📍 When to Choose a Private Attorney Over a Public Defender in Florida
Hiring a private attorney is ideal if:
✅ You’re facing a felony or serious misdemeanor
✅ You have a professional license or immigration concerns
✅ You want to explore suppression motions or aggressive plea negotiations
✅ You value ongoing updates, control, and strategy
A private attorney can also step in before charges are filed, possibly stopping the case early. Public defenders only get involved after formal charges are brought.
📌 Related:Top Reasons to Hire a Broward Criminal Defense Attorney
⚖️ What If I Can’t Afford a Private Lawyer?
We understand private representation can be an investment. That’s why we offer:
Free consultations
Transparent flat fees
Payment plans in eligible cases
Honest assessments of what your case needs
Your future is worth a conversation.
📞 Considering a Public Defender? Talk to Us First.
We’ve represented thousands of clients across Fort Lauderdale, Hollywood, and Broward County. As a former prosecutor, Michael White knows both sides of the courtroom—and how to use that experience to your advantage.
📞 Call (954) 270-0769 or request your free case review. We’ll tell you whether private representation makes sense for your case.
🙋♂️ FAQs: Public Defender vs. Private Criminal Attorney
Q1: Are public defenders good lawyers?
✅ Many are—but they’re overworked. They may not have the time or resources to explore every possible defense.
Q2: When should I hire a private criminal attorney?
⚖️ If your charge is serious, or your job, license, or immigration status is at risk, private counsel gives you more control and strategy.
Q3: Is it expensive to hire a private defense lawyer?
💵 It depends on your case. Flat fees and payment plans may be available, and consultations are often free.
Q4: Can I switch from a public defender to a private attorney?
🔄 Yes. You can change at nearly any point before trial.
Q5: Will the judge think I’m guilty if I hire a lawyer?
🚫 No. Hiring a lawyer means you’re protecting your rights—nothing more.